Nissan Motor on Tuesday threw cold water on hopes for a quick fix to its strained relations with France’s Renault SA, saying inequality between the partners could unravel their two-decade-old automaking alliance.
Speaking at Nissan’s annual general meeting in Yokohama, its first since the dramatic ouster of former chairman Carlos Ghosn last year, Chief Executive Hiroto Saikawa said he wanted to preserve the spirit of equality in the alliance – despite a shareholding structure that Nissan has long seen as lopsided.
Tuesday’s meeting comes just days after the two partners resolved a highly publicized disagreement between Saikawa and Renault Chairman Jean-Dominique Senard over appointments to Nissan’s newly created governance committees.
“We want a win-win relationship with Renault. The alliance has been successful until now because we have respected each others’ independence,” Saikawa said.
“If necessary, we will put our capital structure on the table. If the relationship becomes a win-lose one, the relationship will break up very quickly.”
His comments are some of the starkest in recent memory about the alliance and signal Nissan’s deepening concern over the relationship.
“Our priority is to recover our performance, which means postponing discussions on the future of the alliance,” Saikawa told shareholders.
“It is critical to create opportunities in the future with Renault to discuss options for the alliance. I want to discuss these with Senard.”
Shareholders at Japan’s second-biggest automaker voted on a new governance structure and 11-member board, after the arrest last year of Ghosn over financial misconduct allegations – which he denies – revealed auditing weaknesses at the company.
Renault, Nissan’s biggest shareholder with 43.4% of the Japanese automaker, had demanded additional representation for its directors on Nissan groups overseeing company auditing and personnel nominations.
Saikawa had initially pushed back at those demands, but late last week Nissan granted seats to Senard and Renault CEO Thierry Bollore on its nominations and auditing committees, respectively.
Although that maneuvering helped pull the Nissan-Renault alliance back from the brink of crisis – and may have saved Saikawa’s job – the former Ghosn lieutenant is now faced with the unenviable task of trying to shore up the strained partnership.
Nissan shareholders on Tuesday also returned Saikawa to the board of the automaker, as expected. Reappointment sees him defy opposition by proxy advisors.
In a rare public rebuke by international proxy firms against the leader of a top-tier Japanese firm, International Shareholder Services and Glass Lewis earlier this month urged Nissan shareholders to vote against reappointing Saikawa as a director.